THE VOICE OF REASON IN A SECULAR AGE

Blog by Ian Linden
07/10/2026

Britain seems constrained to join other European States in re-armament.  Putin’s fantasy of Ukraine’s return to the Russian Federation and a restoration of the former Soviet territory , Xi Jinping’s determination to absorb Taiwan by all means available, seem utterly intractable, a grave injustice if accomplished.  Military deterrence is an understandable response.   At one level, this ‘confrontational logic’ seems to make sense.   But it is ultimately the victory of emotion over reason. 

After earlier this year the Pope had taken the USA and Trump to task over the war in Iran, Leo didn’t shy away from addressing  Europe and its leaders on preparations for war, though less forcefully, in a speech at the Robert Schuman Centre in Metz on 28 September.  He compared their present stance to the vision of the founding fathers of the European Union, an exemplar of peaceful relations, making in Schuman’s words “any war…not only unthinkable but materially impossible” . 

“Today we must ask whether we are truly making ‘creative efforts’ to advance world peace”, the Pope said “or whether we are simply seeking to ‘stem the tide of war’ and better prepare ourselves for wars that we assume are still to come”.  The title of his talk was “The Roots of Europe for Peace and Unity”; Schuman and De Gasperi were clearly influenced by their Catholicism in their founding vision for post-war Europe.  It is an important reminder but not one a nation blighted by BREXIT is likely to heed, even given a Prime Minister with a Catholic upbringing.  Least of all with Putin’s war of aggression  – the majority of Ukrainians wish to be European not a part of the Russian Federation –  gaining in intensity and threats.

“World peace cannot be safeguarded if constructive efforts are not made commensurate with the dangers that threaten it” as the Pope put it.  And these dangers are obvious, not least to young people who may have to live through their consequences as diplomacy risks becoming seen as a futile if necessary routine.  Leo steers a difficult, but traditional, course rejecting “a naïve form of pacifism” balancing the right to self-defence against a condemnation of “repeated calls to increase military spending and the choices that follow” – which today appear to many as thoroughly justified for self-defence.

There isn’t much moral wriggle-room for Christians to be drawn from the early Church’s witness to non-violence.  Nor in Matthew 26.52: “Put your sword back in its place” as Peter acts to defend Jesus.  I was very fortunate to get to know the late Bruce Kent in the last years of his life and  to develop a great admiration for his work, that of his wife, Valerie Flessati and Pax Christi.  They are far from naïve.  And they are, and have been, creative in their peace-making despite minimal support from the Hierarchy.  At another level, the Vatican’s Pontifical Ecclesiastical Academy, answerable to the Secretariat of State, trains its diplomats, nuncios, in diplomacy, and has traditionally given peace-making and peace-building top priority as an aspect of evangelisation.  They should not be criticised for engaging diplomatically with tyrannical and authoritarian regimes.  Especially given this is deemed impossible for Western democratic States except intermittently, clandestinely and at their peril. 

In the 2025 reckoning by the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) , global expenditure on weapons amounted to  $2,887 billion, 2.5% of global GBP.  Or in figures that you can take in, each person on earth spent $325 dollars to kill each other or prevent that happening, money which might have fed them or contributed to building a school – instead of bombing it.  The parents of the 120 children killed by a US bomb in Minab school, Tehran, wrote to thank the Pope for his anguished words, calling him “the voice of the voiceless children”. 

The UK Foreign Office once had officers dedicated solely to human rights working in British Embassies and High Commissions.  No more.  Specialists survive in local politics and economics, or rather investment, selling British goods, fostering favourable relations with the UK, plus military attachés, and MI6 under diplomatic cover.  And of course, ambassadors increasingly outpaced by data flows through social media, responsible for insightful reports to London, and social gatherings of the good and the great, words in ears over canapés.  The old Department for International Development, budget plundered, the poor relative now merged with the Foreign Office.  Staffing ‘commensurate with the dangers that threaten world peace?”  I don’t think so. 

But imagine just 1% of the forthcoming UK military expenditure up to 2035 being spent on Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office (FCDO) staffing by experts in peace-making and peace-building, and in training diplomats with fluency in Chinese, Russian and Arabic for dialogue with despots.  It is a choice.  Fanciful perhaps but not ‘naïve pacifism’.  Would their work make a difference?  Some.  Building mutual trust is a marathon not a sprint.  But listening, goodness and virtue in the long term can be literally disarming – as Leo points out.  If there is any hope of swinging the balance from – manipulated – emotion to reason, a thoroughly Catholic strategy, such an earmarked, increased allocation to peace-building by the FCDO must be made.

If diplomatic efforts are not significantly and dramatically increased, we will remain trapped in confrontational logic and repeated defeats for democracy as, in Pope Leo’s words, “people boast of lies and deceptions”.    It is an irony that in this, our secular epoch which claims descent from the Enlightenment, it is a Pope, growing in popularity, who provides the voice of reason.

“SUICIDAL EMPATHY” & CATHOLICISM

Blog by Ian Linden
25/08/2026


Right-wing extremist ways of bringing religion and ethics into politics seem to be gaining ground.  Reform’s recent attempt to redefine empathy is a further example.  They are all interlinked so this gambit is particularly dangerous.   If they weren’t connected, Catholic Social Teaching would be all good intentions and no action. 

Gad Saad invented the term ‘suicidal empathy’.  He spent a decade in Concordia – formerly  a Canadian Jesuit University – becoming Research Chair in Evolutionary Behavioural Sciences and Darwinian Consumption (be reassured Darwinian Consumption is not the fittest eating the unfit).  Saad’s expertise is in consumer behaviour and marketing, food for Reform.  His book Suicidal Empathy: Dying to be Kind was published in May this year and provided the main fodder for attacking the value of empathy.  Lebanese born, Jewish, atheist, and polemicist, he recently left Canada. He felt threatened by, and had himself experienced, antisemitism (6,800 incidents in 2025 up 9% on 2024).   He didn’t like their immigration policy,  ‘wokeism’ and the tax system.  Saad currently does research in one of the most conservative US States, at the University of Mississippi. 

Politics, Religion and Morality together are about how we live together as societies.  As a section of the American evangelicals demonstrate, Christianity is not immune to Saad’s type of  manipulation.  Islam and Judaism suffer in the same way.

The recent Reform ploy, picking up on Saad’s argument that ‘infectious ideas are killing common sense’, is an attempt to rubbish an understanding of empathy that is politically inconvenient.  In a 16 August Press Conference, former Tory Minister Robert Jenrick, now Treasury spokesman for Reform,  set out policy changes to save £50 billion on disability and immigration, describing it as countering ‘suicidal empathy’.  The wording seems to have some resonance.  ‘Suicidal empathy’ was given another airing as the theme in last week’s Channel’s 4’s Moral Maze. 

Empathy is not a word that features much in Catholic writing.  But it fits well as a secular version of compassion, or at least a hyphenated version com-passion, with/for someone who is suffering.  Here is Pope Francis’ Angelus sermon on 3 August 2014: “compassion — which Jesus feels — it is not simply feeling pity; it’s more!  It means to suffer with,  in other words to empathize with the suffering of another, to the point of taking it upon oneself.  Jesus is like this: he suffers together with us, he suffers with us, he suffers for us.  And the sign of this compassion is the healing of countless people he performed. Jesus teaches us to place the needs of the poor before our own”.  The striking image of the Church as field hospital.

By way of contrast, Reform is also picking up on a MAGA theme promoted by Vice-President Vance of ‘concentric circles’ of moral responsibility, family nation and, outermost, overseas aid.    This spatial ranking is used to justify drastic cuts in international development aid in times of financial austerity.  The parable of the Good Samaritan, of course,  specifically  and deliberately counters this for Christians.  As Pope Francis responded to Vance: “Christian love is not a concentric expansion of interests that little by little extend to other persons and groups.” This rejection of a ranking in the focus of Christian love, agape, has also been re-iterated by Pope Leo. 

Though empathy isn’t one of the Catholic virtues, it is clearly important in our ability to ‘activate’ the theological, God-given, virtue of charity.  Emotional and cognitive empathy, feeling for and understanding someone else’s pain, could also be seen as a necessary component of the natural, cardinal virtue of justice, the will to do good.  Alistair McIntyre, following Aristotle,  insists in his 1981 Virtue Ethics the virtues involve practice and a sense of direction in life, a purpose, a teleology or meaningful end.  Nor is empathy a kind of super-virtue.  Prudence, the ability to choose the right virtue in a particular moral situation, has more claim to be called that.

I first bumped into the importance of empathy whilst working with an insightful psychologist  countering religious and right-wing extremism in a non-governmental initiative.  There had been much US government emphasis on websites countering the misuse of Qu’ranic verses but, of course, jihadist recruits weren’t looking at them.  Our focus was on the way the extremist mind worked.    In sessions with young people at risk,  a numerical scale put together through complex monitoring of the frequency of certain phrases and words, indicated levels of extremist risk.

Of course a critical question was at what level of risk was violent action ‘triggered’.  Rather like the chance of a vehicle killing someone  – it suddenly increases sharply  above 30mph – there is a steep curve into a danger zone to a ‘tipping point’ past which terrorism is on the cards.  But, as part of a psychologist’s tool kit, there is in existence another scale which maps  almost exactly, though inversely, onto  the extremism template: for empathy.

The extremist mind has a number of features but the most obvious is an absence of emotional and cognitive empathy.  This was associated with a ‘them and us’ binary view of the world and an inability to perform a process of integrating conflicting ideas and moral values, part of cognitive empathy.  Instead, over time or sometimes suddenly,  this sequence  can take place. “They do not see the world as we see the world”.  They are ‘the other’.  They are wrong and bad. They must be rejected.  They have to be eliminated”.  This descent into violence responds to emotional needs found in both extremes, Islamic jihadists and right-wing terrorists.  Jihadist grooming was a process of providing a sense of belonging, justifying the anger in angry young men, and  getting rid of any empathy that might influence their attitude to ‘the enemy’.  And sadly some 40% of jihadists, in jail, at large, on trial, have experienced some degree of mental illness.

‘Suicidal empathy’ would be a good description of the relationship between an extremist suicide bomber and their community of jihadists.   So Saad and Reform might stop to think about how their story about ‘suicidal empathy’, motivated by a wish to cling to a pure belonging,  to an imaginary identity and group, results in a de facto rejection of ‘the other’. Comparisons can indeed be odious.
​
I hope this isn’t unfair and shows some understanding of Professor Saad. He would have some good advice on increasing the market for, say, rosary beads, or hot-cross buns.  But I’ll take a rain-check, as the Americans say, on his particular purée of religion, morality and politics.

Reform’s embrace of Gad Saad’s ideas is designed  to increase dislike and fear of Muslims and to use his polemics for their own political ends.  Empathy with Muslims – our contemporary religious version of Samaritans – needed curtailing.  Enter Gad Saad, culture warrior, to direct the traffic by on the other side.

Lebanon: The Real War and the War of Words – Ian Linden

“The abuse and manipulation of God’s name to justify this and any other war is the gravest sin we can commit at the present time”.
 Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, Patriarch of Jerusalem, 17 March 2026.

What do Peter Hegsmith, US Secretary of Defence, Naim Qassem, secretary-General of Hezbollah, and Itamar Ben-Gvir, Israeli Minister of National Security, have in common?  They all believe that military force is there to fulfill their version of God’s will.  Deus Vult, God Wills it. That their use of force does not conform to the laws of war does not seem to bother them.  Their own might is always right because it has a divine purpose whether inspired by Christian nationalism, extreme forms of Islamist thinking or Zionist Judaism. 

Modern warfare  has become an exercise in increasing the distance between those perpetrating the killing and the reality on the ground.  ‘Collateral damage’ sounds like storm damage – to a building.  But those words frequently indicate dead and maimed children, women and other non-combatants.  Political leaders, military chiefs and nuclear scientists,  called ‘high value targets’,  are “taken out”, not assassinated.  With them often die their wives, children, and friends; it has been reported that Israel calibrates the number deemed acceptable against the estimated importance of each target.  ‘States have “capabilities”: the vast array of technical resources capable of overwhelming an enemy not their capacity to resolve conflict diplomatically.  Vague euphemisms, the ‘cuttlefish ink’ Orwell described  in his 1946 essay “Politics and the English Language”, are spurted out daily trying to obscure what television news reveals thanks to courageous war correspondents. 

At the opposite pole from military euphemism is the word ‘terrorist’, covering a multitude of sins.  The once functional definition of terrorism – violent actions by a sub-state actor to achieve political goals by instilling fear in communities is increasingly inadequate.   States themselves can, and do, terrorise their citizens.  Iran is an obvious example.  Sub-state actors become a part of a government, or at some point take over the State itself.  If terrorism simply means violence to achieve political aims there is no moral reason not to accuse brutal States of ‘terrorism’   Madeleine Albright, US Secretary of State under President Bill Clinton 1997-2001 pointed out – at a later date – that the United States has often had “limited success when declaring war against nouns”.

Slovenly use of language creates a pernicious loop with what Orwell called ‘foolish thoughts’ and with what we today call ‘spin’.  This loop characterises the arsenal of disinformation and propaganda used to quieten citizens’ moral concerns about today’s wars.  Had he not been a “Christian atheist” confronted by totalitarianism, Orwell might have added how misuse of language and poor theology links to ‘foolish thoughts’ about war and God’s will.  Christian nationalists are a good example.

Just war theory, both Islamic and Christian, makes the distinction between combatants and non-combatants.  But the nature of today’s weapons,  modern warfare, the relationships within civil society created by Islamist dispensations, or implanted in other religious communities by propagandists, makes distinguishing actual combatants more difficult.  Today’s war in the Lebanon makes it almost impossible.   If a war is God’s Will, it seems, the Divine Will overrides moral restraints.

Trump and his circle convince themselves with their own misleading language.  Given the information available to his Intelligence agencies, the US Administration’s misconception about  likely reaction to their attack on Iran is startling.   Iran obviously had been long preparing for war and would prove a resolute opponent, drawing in Hezbollah, yet the White House didn’t anticipate blocking of the Straits of Hormuz.

Hezbollah’s origins lie in the war between Israel and the Palestinians and Israel’s 1978 and 1982 invasions of Lebanon targeting refugees and the Palestine Liberation Organisation’s (PLO) militia.  Lebanon had fallen apart into a civil war between ten different religious communities and their militias, segregated along sectarian lines. 

Export of its 1979 Islamic revolution was the foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran lead by Ayatollah Khomenei.  Hezbollah initially saw itself as an integral part of this new dispensation.  In 1983 it placed bombs by the US embassy and marine barracks killing 241 Americans.   The Ta’if Agreement mediated by Saudi Arabia and brokered by the Arab League, designed to end Lebanon’s civil war, was signed in 1989:  Hezbollah was recognised as the sole militia responsible for future resistance. 

Modelled on Iran, Hezbollah created a multi-layered pyramidal structure for governance: a Majlis Shura al-Qarar, a consultative council of seven primarily clerical members, Sheik Naim Qassem amongst them, elected every three years by a convention of some 250 Hezbollah top cadres.  There are executive, political, judicial, jihad/security and the parliamentary work, councils. By 1992 Ayatollah Khamenei, successor to Khomenei, was recommending Hezbollah adopt a policy of Infitah: participation  in Lebanon’s elections.   They maintain on average ten deputies in Lebanon’s parliament and are guaranteed two Government Ministers.

According to Joseph Daher’s Hezbollah: The Political Economy of Lebanon’s Party of God, Pluto Press 2016, Hezbollah developed organisations for health, education, seminary training,  orphans, and emergency aid.  Islam compliant loans, zakat tithing, donations and discount cards aided the poor.  An extensive education system plus a TV network, radio station and publishing outlets inculcated the principal of Iltizam, religious commitment and adherence to strict Islamist practice including the duty of supporting Hezbollah. 

Houses were rebuilt after bombing raids honouring the slogan ‘reconstruction, resistance and rebirth’.  Disciplined lives became prosperous lives; a Shi’a middle class grew. The vision was a pure society uncorrupted by the West, an Islamic milieu, hala islamiyya, a ‘resistance society’ against the Zionist enemy. The provision of public services and charitable outreach, a  ‘combination of consent and coercion’, in Daher’s words, encouraged Lebanese Shi’a acceptance of Hezbollah’s authority. 

Southern Lebanon, predominantly Shi’a, dotted with small towns with some ancient Christian villages, now under Israeli attack, has an agricultural economy.   Its people are farmers plus well-off entrepreneurs, landowners and Hezbollah local government officials.  There are possibly 60,000 fighters including part-time reservists and a UN peacekeeping force reduced to 7,500 mandated to secure a buffer zone south of the Litani river.   A significant Shi’a community lives in the more mixed northern Beqaa Valley.

It is easy, especially in war time, to interpret attempts to understand a party to a conflict as support for that party.   Support is clearly not the intention of Daher’s Hezbollah.   Nor is it mine.  But for several reasons, including future negotiations, ignorance is not bliss as  the Middle East today demonstrates.
With its armed wing, trained by the Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), Hezbollah poses an intractable problem for Lebanon’s army and government.  Its rocket attacks provide Israel with their perennial justification for prolonged invasions of Lebanon and the bombing of “Hezbollah strongholds”.  Over one million people, 18% of Lebanon’s population, have had to abandon their homes as the invading Israeli Defence Force (IDF) pushes further into the South again.  In Dahieh, a densely populated southern suburb of Beirut,  controlled by Hezbollah residents cannot easily be sorted into combatants and non-combatants.  Bombs hit buildings which collapse burying people under rubble In Dahieh as in Gaza  The death toll is already above 1,000, 10% children. 

An infinite gulf exists between the Will of a loving, merciful and compassionate God and the will to power that States, and non-state actors, exert in war.  It cannot be bridged – least of all by euphemistic language, ignorance and disinformation.  On his right biceps, Peter Hegseth has a Deus Vult tattoo.  A  chant from the First Crusade, it marks the clear and present danger of Christian Nationalism.

Nostalgia is not a strategy – Professor Ian Linden

The UN, WTO, WHO, the COP, multilateral institutions on which the world relied, the collective scaffolding intended to build a secure, peaceful, international order, we can rely on no longer.  Three superpowers led by autocratic rulers, China, Russia and the USA, for whom in Hannah Arendt’s words “the distinction between fact and fiction no longer holds”, rule a divided world where Might is Right.  Both theologically and geopolitically we urgently need a plan.

“ We aim to be both principled and pragmatic, principled in our commitment to fundamental values, sovereignty, territorial integrity, the prohibition of the use of force, except when consistent with the UN Charter, and respect for human rights, and pragmatic recognizing that progress is often incremental, that interests diverge, that not every partner will share all of our values”. It – unusually – received a standing ovation.

What does “principled and pragmatic” look like theologically?  Well, the covenant promises between God and humanity, and for that reason between people in shared action for the common good.  Christian hope is confidence in God’s New Testament promises for the future,  providing the purpose and endurance for a long road ahead.

Politics is about the promises we make to each other.  In The Human Condition 1958, Hannah Arendt presents these as our hedge against unpredictability, creating “communities of security”.  The  promise of love and compassion provides the glue that will hold the communities together.  Pope Benedict XVI in his magisterial Caritas in Veritate 2009 wrote: “Reason, by itself, is capable of grasping the equality between men and of giving stability to their civic coexistence, but it cannot establish fraternity.   This originates in a transcendent vocation from God the Father, who loved us first, teaching us through the Son what fraternal charity is.” 

Christian forgiveness – counter-intuitively – might be called pragmatic. Demonstrated by the French priests who went into Bergen-Belsen after the Second World War, they refused to discriminate against Germans in their charitable work.  It formed the basis of a reconciled Europe that could co-operate between nations and build strong societies.  Trying to heal the wounds of apartheid, it motivated South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission.  It is needed, alongside justice, to rediscover the  fraternity, the friendships, that Benedict wrote about in a divided world.

Professor Ian Linden